L

LordSardinhas

@LordSardinhas

|

Joined 4 months ago

Submissions

Tell us about a spinoff you'd love to see made!

in Film & TV

Closed

Spinoff Title: Star Wars: Dawn of the Chosen

Premise

What if Anakin Skywalker resisted the lure of the dark side and fulfilled his destiny as the Chosen One by leading the Jedi Order into a new era? In this alternate timeline, Anakin remains steadfast in his loyalty to the Jedi, confronting the corruption in the Republic and bringing balance to the Force—not through destruction but through unity and renewal. The galaxy faces new challenges as the Sith adapt to Anakin's unforeseen resistance, creating a darker, more insidious threat that tests the very fabric of the Jedi's moral code.

Plot Overview

Set during the events of "Revenge of the SITH", Anakin Skywalker refuses to succumb to Palpatine’s manipulation. Instead, he exposes Palpatine’s Sith identity to the Jedi Council. Though Anakin struggles with fear for Padmé’s life, he chooses to trust Obi-Wan and Yoda’s guidance rather than act on his darker impulses.

Palpatine’s arrest sparks a galactic crisis as the Republic fractures, with remnants of the Senate rallying behind the Sith and their promises of order and power. A civil war erupts, but instead of the Empire rising, the galaxy is torn between the Jedi-led Republic and a chaotic alliance of opportunistic warlords and hidden Sith factions.

Anakin, thrust into the role of a wartime leader, faces personal and political challenges. He works alongside Obi-Wan and Ahsoka Tano to reform the Jedi Order, making it more compassionate and less dogmatic. Meanwhile, the Sith adapt to their new underdog status, relying on guerrilla tactics and sowing dissent within the Republic.

As the war progresses, Anakin begins to have visions of a shadowy Sith Lord far more ancient than Palpatine: Darth Plagueis, who has returned from the brink of death to claim the galaxy. The finale sees Anakin leading a united front of Jedi, clones, and rebel factions to confront this primordial threat, culminating in a dramatic showdown that forever reshapes the Force.

Why I'd Love to See It

1. Exploration of Anakin's Potential: This spinoff would allow us to see the heroic Anakin that Qui-Gon Jinn believed in—the Chosen One fulfilling his destiny without falling. His character would still face intense inner conflict, but it would focus on the struggle to lead and evolve without succumbing to fear and anger.

2. Richer Jedi Dynamics: Watching Anakin, Obi-Wan, Yoda, and Ahsoka work together to reform the Jedi Order would be fascinating, especially as they grapple with the flaws that led to their near downfall in the original timeline.

3. A Different Galactic Conflict: Instead of the Empire versus the Rebellion, we’d see a fractured galaxy where no side has overwhelming power. This would create a more morally complex and unpredictable story, as the Jedi navigate new alliances and face unconventional enemies.

4. The Sith as Underdogs: Seeing the Sith operate as a shadowy resistance would make for a fresh dynamic, and the return of Darth Plagueis as a mastermind would introduce a terrifyingly intelligent and powerful villain unlike any seen before.

5. A Deeper Connection to the Force: Without the looming tragedy of Anakin’s fall, the story could delve into the mysteries of the Force, exploring what true balance means and how Anakin’s unique destiny shapes the galaxy.

In essence, "Star Wars: Dawn of the CHOSEN" would combine the epic scale of the original saga with a fresh perspective on its central themes, offering fans a compelling "what if" scenario that redefines the legacy of the Chosen One.

Winner

Tell us about a great overlooked detail in a movie or TV show!

in Film & TV

Closed

overlooked detail in "The Return of the King" lies in Frodo’s subtle transformation and his final act of betrayal at Mount Doom, which is rich with thematic complexity.

WHen Frodo finally reaches the edge of the Crack of Doom, instead of destroying the Ring, he claims it for himself, saying, "The Ring is mine." This moment of betrayal is often seen as a simple culmination of the Ring’s power over him. However, what’s frequently missed is how this reflects a profound commentary on human (or hobbit) frailty and the burden of ultimate power.

From a symbolic perspective, Frodo's failure shows that no one, no matter how pure or resilient, can fully resist the Ring's corrupting influence when tested to the utmost. Tolkien subtly builds to this moment throughout the trilogy, showing how Frodo grows increasingly possessive of the Ring, alienating himself from even his closest companions like Sam. The parallel to Gollum is striking: both started with good intentions, but the Ring’s power eroded their morality and sense of self.

What deepens this moment further is that Frodo is ultimately saved not by his own will, but by Gollum’s obsessive greed. Gollum biting off Frodo’s finger and falling into the lava inadvertently fulfills the quest. This suggests a paradox: evil (Gollum’s greed) is necessary to destroy a greater evil (the Ring). It’s an echo of Tolkien's Catholic worldview, where even the most broken figures can serve a higher purpose, though unwittingly.

Finally, Frodo’s failure casts his later departure to the Undying Lands in a different light. He is not only leaving because of his physical and emotional scars but also because he bears the weight of knowing he succumbed to temptation at the critical moment. His departure isn’t just a healing journey—it’s a tacit acknowledgment of his fallibility, and perhaps even a penance of sorts.

This detail underscores one of Tolkien’s most profound messages: true heroism lies not in perfection or infallibility, but in enduring the consequences of our failures with grace and humility.