community background

Music

Music
Horror and Cats's avatar

I definitely get this to a certain degree. In fact, most people have to pry my musical tastes out of me for exactly why you said—people tend to assess your personality based on the music you listen to.

I’m like you, I like a bunch of one-off songs from tons of artists in many genres. When I was younger I used to latch onto a band as a whole, but for whatever reason I don’t anymore.

Even back then I didn’t wear merch or anything like that. I don’t like to standout/invite conversations from strangers and wearing band T shirts is a great way to do both lol.

I can’t remember what it’s called, but I have issues comprehending speech which isn’t perfectly clear/I can’t read the lips along with, so certain genres/artists are REALLY frustrating to listen if they don’t enunciate. As a result, I too like listening to classical/instrumental when I need to relax. My mind focuses too much on trying to understand lyrics, so it’s not something I can do when trying to focus on anything else.

Damien Mason's avatar

I'm not qualified to say one way or another if it's neurodivergent, but I'd more likely just call it a preference thing. There are so many different things to enjoy in life, and this one thing doesn't quite hit home as much for you as it does for others.

I do think there's an observation we could make about massive phenomena, like Taylor Swift and Swifties. Similar to you, I don't understand the die-hard fanaticism that comes with her music because it transcends pure enjoyment and walks into cult territory for some (not all, of course). More power to anyone excited about a new album release or invested in the narratives behind their favourite artists. After all, I'm heavily invested in Starset's whole backstory and motivation. But when investment becomes obsession to the point that critique is no longer welcome, that's when I check out.

There's nothing wrong with anyone making music a core part of their life or building their personality, fashion, or lifestyle around it. There's also nothing wrong with it being the smallest part of your life. Replace music with geek culture, sports, art, academia, etc., and it's the same deal. We're all drawn to different things.

Music just so happens to be a big part of most people's lives because it has a lot of breadth. I can understand that it must feel a little like looking from the outside in, but you shouldn't feel the need to pretend to fit in. There are so many other things you can connect with others through. In my eyes, there's no difference between meeting someone with different music tastes (the vast majority of people I know) and meeting someone who isn't into music. I just move on to the next most likely commonality.

Thomas's avatar

I'm glad you felt able to post about this and I don't think you should feel weird or worried about it. Different people have different feelings about things and that's what makes us special.

I don't think there's anything wrong with not being into music, but based on what you've said, I wonder if what's happened is that you've not found the music that resonates with you, and maybe you'd like music that's a bit less traditional pop music and more kind of out there.Maybe you should check out some ambient, jazz, noise, electronic or post-rock artists? Off the top of my head, I'd recommend checking out the following:

You might hate all of those, which is fine! Like I said, there's not actually anything wrong with not vibing with music as an artform

FirestormGamingTeam's avatar

TBH, I say the same thing about TV Dramas, some of them I can REALLY get into whilst others, that millions "love" I find sad and pathetic.

I think music is much the same, this being said, my music taste in terms of what I mostly listen to is artists such as Two Steps From Hell, I find most mainstream music to be sad, lonely music always talking about love and falling in love and this that and the other.

So no my friend, you are not abnormal, you simply are much like me and a few people on here, we do not follow the mass hysteria and we are not sheep to be guided by the others interests.

Konquest's avatar

I do get what you are saying to a certain degree. I myself personally don't really get attached to a particular band, neither am I obsessed. I do admit that music influences my mood like how classical music can take me back to a memory, how some trance and sentimental can give me the feels, how Doom Eternal's soundtrack makes me feel immortal. I even listen to music in languages that I don't understand, I have a very wide selection that no one knows what I actually listen to :D

I know people around me who can life totally without music at all as well, when I asked them they told me it just sounds like noise to them and I respect that. I think everything is subject to different opinions and views. I play music and have written some myself, I used to be in a cover band. I do love music but at times I appreciate total silence as well. I don't know if that helps any but just thought I'd share.

Dave's avatar

Thanks all. I won't reply to all but try and cover it here.

I get we all enjoy different things and for example my wife is not interested in games in the slightest and can't understand why anyone would want to sit there for a decent 3 hour session playing one. Or a lot of people are into sport and others aren't. Music seems to hit differently though as this universal appeal to all that everyone enjoys, hence used often as conversation topics (like the weather). So it feels pretty unusual not really having anything to say about it.

The things I've been to that I do tend to enjoy more are when there's a large variety like a festival etc when it's not just one band. Then it's fairly likely there will be something that is at least a little bit enjoyable, but not a band as a whole, maybe just one or 2 of the things they play.

Its not like I actively don't like it as such, the from the outside looking in sums it up quite well. Like in the IT crowd, they pretend to like football and use a website that tells then what to say, so funny but so real as well! Lol.

https://youtu.be/Sasksdm1Ftc?si=Q93fOP_6OPaM0y4Z

This is actually happening to me right now! It's pretty funny really. I went with my wife to a local music pub that always has cover bands on. I enjoyed it but really I was just there for something to do together, get out and have a few drinks.

One of my neighbours saw us there, now every time I see the guy in the street, he stops me and talks about the band we saw, similar acts and who we are going to see next. In the interests of neighbourly relations and getting on with people, I have this whole conversation with him about all this music stuff he thinks I'm interested in and really I don't have a clue what he's talking about or what I'm saying!

Dave's avatar

Just to clarify here. obviously my wife knows I'm not really into music and I was just going for something to do!

Sturmer's avatar

It's fascinating how diverse our experiences with music can be. Like you, I believe in the importance of not judging others' connections or lack thereof with music. Everyone engages with art in their own unique way, and it’s essential to respect these differences. Extreme reactions, like those you fear about fitting in, sadly reflect broader issues where people feel pressured to conform to the majority's emotional responses.

It's crucial that we foster an environment where all perceptions, including those who might not 'feel' the music as deeply, are equally valued and accepted.

emoji

Join the conversation!

Some of the best conversations on the internet are happening here - and our users are getting rewarded for having them. Don't miss out!

sunglasses emojiemoji pointing left

Communities

There’s more to love

Help shape the future of our platform as we build the best place to express and enjoy your passions, whatever they may be.

Emoji

© Just About Community Ltd. 2024