I have loved everyone that I've played, but I think Dark Souls 3 just takes it for my favourite. The music in Firelink Shrine still gives me goosebumps.
Unfortunately I haven't had a chance to play Bloodborne or Demon Souls as I don't have access to a PlayStation. I have however watched full playthroughs of both on YouTube and am very much looking forward to the day I get to play them.
(Sorry if I missed one)
Created at . Page last updated at .
Honestly out of all of those its Elden Ring for me, it's just "better"
I've only played Bloodborne and Sekiro, but I've seen a lot about the other's on the list and I'm pretty confident Bloodborne would remain my fav. Just aesthetically it wins out, but also I connect with the emphasis on aggression.
Oddly enough, i played soulslike games not developed by genre originator :)
Ashen is great
Dark Souls is my favourite game ever. I always felt like the sequels didn't quite manage to capture the magic. That sense of exploration or the slow, weighty combat. Elden Ring came close in a lot of ways, though.
I also absolutely adore Bloodborne which would be a close second, for bringing its own thing to the table and still feeling totally unique in its tone and feel.
I cant speak from a Place of huge knowledge, I have played a little bit of Dark souls 2 and a lot of Bloodbourne, But, defo Really like the vibe, aesthetic and the design !
I might have to play it again soon !
I'd watched people play Dark Souls, Dark Souls 3, and Bloodborne. I'd tried them all and couldn't get past the first boss. Then came Elden Ring and it clicked better for me, even managed to platinum it on the Playstation (not without a lot of rage). Can't wait for more with the upcoming DLC
Some of the best conversations on the internet are happening here - and our users are getting rewarded for having them. Don't miss out!
Help shape the future of our platform as we build the best place to express and enjoy your passions, whatever they may be.
© Just About Community Ltd. 2025
